Before helping to sell a collection, consider this.

“I’ve been asked by a good friend to sell some family papers for her,” a recent email began. “They are personal papers of a Major General and comprise material from his time at West Point to his death in 1944. There is a lot of stuff, correspondence with FDR, many scrapbooks, and hand written material relating to the training of an armored division.” The writer continued, “I have only just started reviewing the material but was wondering if you could provide any guidance for me in my efforts to sell it.”

Though the details vary, this is a common sort of correspondence that comes across my desk. Generally, the correspondence comes from a well-meaning person who is going to help a widow of a collector or someone else who wants the advice of “an expert.”

My advice is usually the same: Identify what you have, determine how you want to sell it, and establish a timeline for the project to come to some sort of conclusion. While the advice is essentially the same, selling an “archival” collection (that is, a collection of primarily documents) is much harder and requires even more effort than if you were asked to sell a collection of rifles, helmets, or Jeeps:

  1. As with any collection for sale, it all begins with identifying what you have. That can be a long process, but it goes a long way to maximizing the revenue.  A good inventory lets a prospective buyer know what it is there, but also lets him know that YOU know what is there.
  1. Decide HOW you want to sell it:
    1. Piece by piece is a long process, but you will maximize the return.
    2. As a group makes the process short, but generally results in less money. Dealers who buy collections tend to buy below wholesale.
  1. Decide on your cut of the pie BEFORE you take on the project—and have a written agreement with the owner. Too many enter into one of these projects believing they are “helping a friend” to sell a collection. Invariably, it turns out to be longer and more work than ever imagined. Make sure you make an allowance to be compensated for your efforts, that the owner of the collection agrees to the terms before you start.

Your formal agreement should also compensate you if nothing sells or just a portion of the collection sells You still need to have an agreement for your time and effort.

Selling someone else’s collection is a huge commitment. If you don’t have a formalized agreement before you begin to work on it, the tension can sometimes result in some very hard—often irreparable—feelings.

  1. Marketing the collection can often involve more time and effort than you might imagine. Finding a buyer for a collection can often take months. Archival collections can often be very slow sellers. An archival collection needs more than famous signatures to make it saleable. You need famous signatures on original, interesting documents to make an archival collection desirable.  Just a Patton signature isn’t that rare, but a Patton signature ordering troop movements to Bastogne would hold some heavy value.

If money isn’t a factor and this is a collection belonging to one person, consider a donation of an archival collection to the soldier’s alma mater or to the US Army Museum in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. With archival collections, the historical significance often outstrips the monetary worth.  Keeping the collection intact is a good way to serve the memory of the soldier and future scholarship.

Hopefully, this advice will give you the information you need to make a decision about getting involved in the sale of the material and then moving forward. But remember, even though you will be selling historic material, the stories about the soldiers who used the material are what truly makes a collection “valuable”—regardless of the price tag on it.

Preserve the memories,

John Adams-Graf

Editor, Military Trader and Military Vehicles Magazine

 

 

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts

2 thoughts on “Before helping to sell a collection, consider this.

  1. leylander on said:

    How about this consideration. . .does this archival material need to be sold on the collectors market at all? Primary material from significant figures is an important part of the history and heritage of this country. Perhaps the material that is “for sale” would better serve if the collection were passed intact to an academic repository. In most peoples’ minds that means “donate” but that isn’t necessarily the case. Any number of institutions would be happy to receive this hypothetical collection, if it came as a donation. The number still interested if the collection came with a price tag decreases but not all archives and special collections are impoverished. The benefits of shopping the collection around to academic buyers are obvious, one buyer takes the lot, no need to sell a bit to this collector or that and, most importantly, the collection remains together as a whole and is available for students and researchers for generations to come. A caveat though, don’t presume that just any archive wants the material. Find and target institutions where the material for sale (or being donated) fits within the scope of their collection.

    • John Adams-Graf on said:

      Excellent point. Most archival collections have far more historic value than monetary value. If broken up, they lose even that historic value.

      Good places to look for a repository begin with the soldier’s hometown or college alma mater. After that, considering a branch of service museum or archives might be the best way to keep it accessible to future researchers.

      Good discussion. Thank you, Leylander, for sharing your thoughts! –JAG

Leave a Reply